I recently came across an article discussing how multiple botanical gardens were ripping out at least some of their beds featuring native plant communities, beds that were installed for educational purposes, as models for homeowners to mimic. There was some controversy about the veracity of the article, some claiming it to be a product of AI. Whether or not that is true it caused me to think about my own experience of attempting to create a native garden here in the high desert of Central Oregon that took as its model the complex of grassland, sagebrush steppe and juniper woodland that once covered this area, as well as my experience of several decades maintaining multiple acre Park sites, with a shrinking budget, an experience that lead me to examining my work schedule and practices, which I was realizing more and more, often put us at cross purposes with the idea of a sustainable landscape that requires little labor and fewer outside resources to maintain them in a healthy state. In an increasingly urbanized/disturbed world in which people are less and less likely to have a ‘working’ relationship with the natural world, i think that it is absolutely essential that we reexamine our relationships with nature and its biotic communities to correct those commonly accepted practices and attitudes that are leading us further down the path of ecological instability and potential crises. How we garden, whether we garden at all, speaks powerfully to our human relationship with the rest of nature.
As I continue my on gardening in central Oregon, I’m learning everyday. The consequences of my mistakes often coming back rapidly, multiplied…sometimes tipping my new native garden’s development into chaos, or at least, in directions I had never intended for it to go.This is due to my own ignorance, the inevitability of our incomplete knowledge, of not just this particular site, but of how the area plant communities of native grassland, Sagebrush Steppe and Juniper Woodland, work together, cycling from one into the other over long periods of time, in never quite the same way. All gardens are experiments. We design them. They are human contrivances, intentionally built from plants we’ve chosen for a variety of our own reasons. The fact that our palette is comprised of local natives, doesn’t mean that we may ‘assemble’ them however we may like. The act of creating a native garden on a site, completely and utterly stripped of its native plants and the relationships that once held between them, is an act of hope and desire, even a degree of hubris, and as powerful as our intentions may be, we are ultimately ignorant of the relationships between all of those plants we might plant there, as well as the living things on, and below the soil in these new beds and gardens, things that are essential for the long-term life of a native garden and its plant community.
We create our landscape design, layout its areas, create its paths, do the necessary grading work, create or enhance its physical features, and acquire the plants on our thoughtful list, and then plant our little native idyll. But a vital plant community is not just a collection of plants, no matter how sensitive and informed our selection of them has been. All plants grow in relationship, which include not just the physical characteristics of a site, which we might focus on, but also those biotic relationships between the plants and those organisms they ‘share’ the space with. Often overlooked are those below the soil surface and with those organisms far too small for us to readily see. The root associations below the ground, the bacteria, mycorrhizae, all the fungal associates in the soil, the insects, protists, even viruses and unnamed, unseen, single celled organisms that populate the soil, are all there in relationship, competing with one another, but also contributing, in myriad ways, to those conditions that shape all of the relationships on that site, in that biotic community. It is never just the plants and ‘dirt’.
When we move into a new home and create a garden, a new park, or a bed for educational purposes in a botanic garden, we are working on a disturbed site, absent their functional healthy biotic support community. Our every action can be understood as a disturbance, especially when it is undertaken without consideration of the life and conditions already there as well as those absent. Even if our clearing of a site of an original native community is followed within months of the disturbance, all those subsurface associations, those relationships, have already deteriorated. All those bacteria, fungi, assorted microbes, and insects carry on their lives at different times scales than our own. A few months to us may not seem like a big deal, but in a landscape upended by mechanical equipment, suffering the onslaught of multiple pesticides, applications of chemical fertilizers, changed grades, the breaking and compaction of the soil surface, the introduction of exotics intended and not, the addition of organic and mineral amendments, the endless ‘tinkering’ undertaken over the establishment period, our sometimes ‘obsessive’ compulsion for neatness, even over the course of a few days, can have a nearly instantaneous, deleterious, effect on these subsoil communities and developing associations. We don’t see the soil chemistry taking place, but our soils are alive, which entails a continuous chain of chemical reactions throughout it, each effecting the other. Some argue that chemistry ‘is life’. When soil pH swings, entire colonies of bacteria may die off and be replaced and those that may not be supportive of your plant selections or of a more ‘stable’ community; that pH is also a major factor in nutrient availability; plant choice, their spacing, those they share the immediate space/root zone with, have a direct bearing on their capacity to survive; disturbances in the form of removals and additions can lead directly to the oxidation/’burning’ of the organic matter in the soil, changing its condition to one no longer supportive of needed soil ‘crumb structure’ so important to soil aeration, water percolation and nutrient retention, ‘glued’ together by certain proteins secreted by some fungi, which in turn are supported by their relationships with others of the biotic community. All of these and many more processes are sustained only in living communities. Our amendments and mechanical tillage can only do so much in maintaining soil ‘health’, while at the same time they themselves may be impeding the more substantive ‘work’ of organisms and processes attributable to healthy native biotic communities. The initial forming matrix of roots of those plants we’ve planted, haven’t reached this ‘balance’ which occurs over time and generational cycles. A healthy biotic community has evolved over time, each member responding to the others, forming networks of naturally formed communities. The living and the dead, cycle and support each other, conserving and releasing nutrients, drawing them and the water back up, that when disrupted are often carried away, down through the soil profile, beyond the root zones of your plants that have yet to weave themselves into a sustainable pattern. Nutrients, that go toward sustaining the community, once held in living and dead plant and animal tissues, in their metabolic and waste products, are thus often lost in disturbance. Plants may have been set out in such a way that their competition weakens them all…but even if they weren’t, even if their spacing and arrangement were ‘ideal’, the other components, the other supports of a cohesive community, aren’t there, as they must develop, evolve over time. Even something as innocuous as applying supplemental irrigation can set the stage for one plant’s success over another, that in the long run, is detrimental to the whole.
Nature, through its healthy plant communities, ‘behaves’ coherently. Site disturbance can break these relationships, the resultant processes, and the outcomes from moment to moment…never finished, are then unable to respond in the context of the whole, its relationships not yet ‘negotiated’. We can work with it or we can set ourselves and our actions outside of its processes…and fail. Whatever it is, this process is not easy. I once had someone memorably remark to me, “How ‘F’ing stupid do you have to be to have to go to college to learn how to grow plants!” That’s the crux of the problem in a nutshell, a generally ignorant public engaged in their own lives, with their own priorities, dismissing the living world of which they have only very rudimentary knowledge of and little interest in understanding. Practice must be tailored to an evolving situation. To care for a landscape, to maintain one in a manner responsive to its needs, requires a degree of engagement. To claim otherwise does no one favors….It should not be too much to expect people, the stewards and carers of the landscapes in which we live, to step up.
Because a problem is difficult doesn’t mean that we shouldn’t try to do this, but it should tell us that our efforts must be sustained, that we must be careful observers, monitoring the responses to our actions and modifying those expectations that we once held, as well as those practices we’ve imposed, while minimizing the disturbance of the site. Disturbance occurs as a result of actions taken that don’t consider the whole. Expedience, efforts to be more ‘efficient’ while dismissing our wider impacts are what transform our actions into true disturbance. We have to consider those changes that have occurred as a result of the changing relationships over time our actions have prompted, relationships between all that is growing and living there. It requires attentiveness and patience as there is no playbook to follow. Projects, both large and small demand that we adopt the practice of adaptive management in which we are active participants in an unfolding, emerging, process. Those model landscapes that we might be attempting to mimic, we have to remember aren’t just a collection of plants growing on the surface and didn’t just spring on to the scene from a blank canvas. Those increasingly rare undisturbed, native plant communities, are the result of the ‘random’ spread of propagules and seed, but random only within the relatively limited context of a suite of plants and conditions that have been ‘active’ across the larger site for thousands of years. The fact that they are there and succeeding, is a result of their ‘fitness’, of appropriate relationship. What succeeds on one site, at a particular point in time, does not mean that that will succeed on another site, even if all the conditions appear to be essentially identical. That site that we’re monitoring, will change, evolve, adapt to their changing relationships, within a range that will be recognizable to the careful observer. Plants, organisms, play different roles in their various communities sometimes dominating one, while in others acting only as a peripheral player. Some are long lived and so shape the community for long periods, while others are ruderal species capable of quickly covering ‘scars’, yielding to the next, seral species, the next role player, before a longer term suite of plants and relationships occupy the site, only to be ‘reset’ by another significant event, a catastrophic fire, landslide, volcanic eruption or perhaps a major flood event. While all of these more frequent calamities occur, there are also those longer term changes to the environment of climatic changes and those driven by plate tectonics those rifts in the crust and lifting of mountain ranges over millions of years. Nature is not a game of fixity. There is no ultimate ‘climax landscape’ that once reached remains forever the same. Everything is in a responsive state of flux.
I made the mistake of attempting to plant members of both grassland and sagebrush steppe communities, an amalgam of plants that wouldn’t normally have appeared together in such a small space, including several native grass species I later found were too aggressive, quickly overwhelming their neighbors. Most of them are native in this immediate locale, but that doesn’t mean that they would all ever exist at the same time, in this particular arrangement, in relationships on a site like this. All the members of any particular plant community possess a slate of requirements necessary for their survive and proliferation, some being very particular, while others are much more aggressive generalists. That doesn’t make them weeds, but they can behave as weeds, possessing that degree of ‘weediness’, of vigor and adaptability, that violates our idea, our intention of what we were trying to create.
It is wrong, or at least misleading, to tell the public that if they plant a native garden, and throw the typical dozen or so local natives at it, that they can then walk away and enjoy their self-sustaining native garden, with little intervention on their part necessary, while also being supportive of wildlife in their limited variety and able to meet the aesthetic demands of someone not attuned to the beauties and limits of the local landscape. Our patterns of habitation, the disturbance of sites caused by these ‘preferred’ patterns of development, often obliterate the natural features of a site along with the previous biotic conditions. We are an imposition on the landscape so it shouldn’t be a surprise that the growing conditions at the micro-level are broken as well. The world is much more than we are prepared to ‘see’. All of this must be taken into account, if we want our gardens, whether formal plantings of exotics, or humble attempts at recreating native communities, we must be sensitive to the disturbance we and our predecessors have imposed on our place. The complexity of native plant communities, and what is required of US to heal the relationships and bridge the wounds of our ongoing disturbance, are central to our success. Ignorance doesn’t give us a pass…and we, are all ignorant in this. Nature will heal itself overtime, if we approach our relationship and gardening with humility, but that healing is likely one that requires many human lifetimes, and require that we adopt a more responsible and sensitive role in that healing, evolving, process. Our continual human disturbance, our tinkering, our regular flipping of landscapes, keeps pushing the reality of a sustainable landscape away and it will be forever so if we continue trying to impose a ‘foreign’ ideal on the places on which we live, an ideal that chooses to ignore the opportunities and limits of the places in which we live. We need to live place oriented lives, which is a tall order for such transient population.
Backyard habitat programs, and appeals to the public to plant natives are a great start, but they are only a start. It’s more than a little disturbing to me, that some botanic gardens might be pulling out their native displays because they aren’t ‘measuring up’ to their earlier claims of minimal maintenance, beauty, biotic ‘utility’, or because their appearance doesn’t meet the public’s expectation. If that’s the case these public gardens need to focus more on public education…that is there purpose after all. A botanic garden shouldn’t be a place filled with ‘perfect’ Disney like display beds, where crews emerge at night to do whatever is necessary to return them to their fantastical form, where the natural cycles and decline are banned. Those kind of places aren’t doing us any favors by perpetuating the fantasy. While they are undoubtedly under pressure to appeal to the public with the flashy, the exotic, the pretty, the perfect, it is essential that botanical gardens help the public understand the role of place in its complexities and the beauty inherent in health and fitness, even the necessity of death and decline, the recycling of nutrients that those processes serve. An entertainment hungry, disengaged public, should not be driving such gardens.
Any complex, healthy landscape will require informed, committed, participation, to succeed long term, not just the skills and commitment of a few experts, but of the people who live in such landscapes. No landscape can survive indifference and the continuous wave of disturbance so many places now suffer. Humans are a part of the natural world. It is only in our walking away from it, our position of ignorant and selfish remove, that we could ever possibly believe such landscapes to be sustainable on their own, while our own actions have either negligible impact, or that the compromised landscape is of little consequence. But this simply isn’t true. Nothing exists on its own.
In fact, the more that we might claim independence, the more we are living our lives in the ‘dark’, ignorant of our consequences, in denial of the ‘local’, the more our survival is at risk. When we do this, when we ignore our connection, our dependence remains, and we put ever more landscapes around the globe, upon which we are then depending, at greater risk, even more so, because halfway around the world, we can never know them. In nature, in life, not only does nothing exist on its own, but there are no true one time fixes, because nothing in life is a one and done process. Rather life is a continuously evolving, unfolding, emerging matrix of complex processes. When we fail to recognize this and remove ourselves from our necessary, responsible role in it, we put it all at risk.
