As a science nerd I found this a fascinating read. Enlightening. I’ve read a lot of science over the last few years and most of these books focus on what the author knows best, on their particular field, their expertise. There are those scientists, more all of the time and science writers today, who are taking a more wholistic view of their subject, joining together all of the ‘bits’ that they are understanding in ever greater detail, and looking at what is emergent, what is a product of the whole, that isn’t revealed in our focused, atomistic, reductionist, traditional approach favored, in fact almost demanded, by those doing science. The author of this book, McFadden, isn’t one of those reductionists.
While his expertise is in molecular genetics, McFadden does not shy away from those other ‘experts’ attempting to put the pieces together to better understand the whole. He himself has done that in an earlier book that he coauthored with, physicist, Jim Al-Kalili, “Life on the Edge: The Coming of Age of Quantum Biology” and in another earlier book, “Quantum Evolution”, which is still on my to read list. In this book he looks more widely at the practice of science, how it influences our understanding of the world/universe/life, how resistant science and society have been to change and how our study of the universe and all that it contains, leads us, at least potentially, to a better, more coherent practice. He builds this around the ideas first formulated by the Franciscan Friar, William of Occam, some of whose ideas later became the standard today commonly known as ‘Occam’s Razor’. Continue reading







